Why Dalton Papali’i’s post-Super Rugby exit for Castres Olympique is a bitter blow for Blues
Tuesday, 17 February 2026
ANALYSIS: As soon as he was tagged as surplus to All Blacks requirements, Dalton Papali’i became a hunted man. It was only a matter of which club would put the right offer in front of the influential loose forward.
Sure enough, the Blues have confirmed that their outstanding No 7, and captain for the early stages of the new Super Rugby Pacific season, will depart the franchise at season’s end to join Castres Olympique in France.
The 37-test All Black and 98-game Blues flanker (he played his first game of them in 2017) joins fellow ex-ABs loosie Hoskins Sotutu (to Newcastle, England) and utility back AJ Lam (to Clermont Auvergne, France), as well as coach Vern Cotter (to the Queensland Reds), in confirming departures at season’s end. Others are sure to follow as clubs make their traditional pre-World Cup raids on fringe or unwanted test talent.
It is considered the ideal time to snap up players who have drifted outside their country’s main test rotation, and might be eager to establish futures before the market is flooded with international regulars looking for post-RWC deals.
Read more:
Papali’i, who could bring up his century of Blues caps as soon as round 3’s visit to the ACT Brumbies, has become a central figure in the Blues’ belated return to the top echelon of the franchise game.
They won the pared-back Covid-reshaped Super Rugby Trans-Tasman competition in 2021 and after being beaten finalists in ‘22’ and defeated semifinalists (both to the Crusaders) in ‘23, they ended a 21-year full championship drought by rolling the Chiefs 41-10 in the 2024 SRP final at Eden Park.
The Blues, after a slow start, were not able to repeat their championship feats in ‘25, but still made it as far as the semifinals, where they went down in a tight contest to – you guessed it – the Crusaders.
The 28-year-old Aucklander has been a near constant presence for the Blues over the last half-dozen or so seasons, and his solid all-round game, staunch physicality and solid link play have made him consistently one of the premier flankers in the New Zealand game.
But he was never able to crack a regular starting spot in the All Blacks, used mostly as backup for Sam Cane, and then very much being cast into the shadow by the rise and rise of Ardie Savea.
After making just four test appearances in ‘24, he was required for duty just once last year, as a replacement in the third July test against France. He was then jettisoned for the Rugby Championship and end-of-year tour, with Du’Plessis Kirifi effectively taking his place in the loose forward rotation.
Papali’i’s exit, alongside that of Sotutu, though inevitable, will be much more of a blow for the Blues than the All Blacks who had clearly moved on from the hard-running loosie.
In many ways he had become the heart and soul of the Auckland franchise and few, if any, forwards have matched his consistency and commitment over the resurgent years.
The worry for new Blues CEO Karl Budge, and whomever comes in to replace Cotter, is that Papali’i and Sotutu, and others set to follow their lead, will leave holes that will take seasons to fill properly.
The Blues have some young talent in their loose stock. Last week’s promising debutant Torian Barnes looks a keeper, they have been developing Anton Segner for just this moment, and Che Clark, Cam Christie and Malachi Wrampling will all relish the opportunities that are about to open up.
But you simply do not replace the experience, the hard-edge and the big-game capabilities of players such as Papali’i and Sotutu without some short-term pain. That seems inevitable for the Blues, as it will other franchises facing similar exits.
Papali’i on Tuesday said it had been the “hardest decision of my life” but one he had made with the best interests of his partner and their young daughter at heart.
“This team has shaped me into the man I am,” he said. “But having a daughter has changed my life. Rugby has been a big part of my life, and I’ve been selfish with that. But rugby is not a long career, you’ve got a short window, and it came down to wanting to financially set my family up, but also having some new goals and a few life experiences.”
He admitted to being piqued by the “daunting” nature of stepping into the unknown by moving to France, but said he had been encouraged by his recent experience back in the NPC with Counties Manukau (after missing All Blacks tour selection, which triggered a release clause in his contract).
“I fell in love with the game again, and found a bit of my flow back. And getting to captain the All Blacks XV under Jamie Joseph was the best thing for me, and one of the best tours I’ve been on because of the hunger from those young players on the fringes.”
Other Blues who could be weighing potential exits include fellow recent internationals halfback Fin Christie, utility back Stephen Perofeta and prop Ofa Tu’ungafasi, as well as veteran hooker Kurt Eklund, while star No 10 Beauden Barrett is off contract after the ‘27 World Cup.
The Blues certainly have some future-planning to take care of.